Berlin (dpa) - Stress is almost guaranteed when flying with a
baby. But many parents find the hunt for a child safety seat,
acceptable to international airlines and in compliance with various
government guidelines, even more stressful.
Making the wrong choice can mean reserving a seat, buying or
renting a safety seat and then learning just before takeoff that the
seat does not pass muster. But not making the effort could mean
foregoing basic safety precautions, some experts say.
Unfortunately, due to a complexity of differing national laws on
child safety in airplanes, to say nothing of varying technical
requirements among airlines and even airplanes in an airline's fleet,
there are few rules of thumb to guide globetrotting parents.
So the quest to find a suitable safety seat for the flight home to
show the baby off to doting grandparents becomes a headache.
Through the haze, two things are clear. Many safety groups say it
is safest to travel with a car seat. And that, thanks to the stew of
sometimes contradictory guidelines, it can be a challenge to figure
out which seat will be accepted by your airline.
"There is no 'global' central place for information," says Alison
Duquette, a spokeswoman for the US Federal Aviation Authority (FAA).
"The best thing I can recommend is that parents contact the airline
they plan to fly with and ask them for their specific rules and
policies."
She notes that some airlines provide their own safety seats and
refuse to let passengers bring their own. But some airlines, who
claim to provide their own child seats, offer conflicting advice
about whether their seats are actually safety seats. To make matters
worse, those seats are often only offered on a first-come,
first-serve basis.
The different takes on child safety in a plane can be dizzying.
The European Union allows parents to secure their children during a
flight with a loop belt - a kind of seat belt that secures the child
to the parent. The Association of European Airlines terms them
"perfectly safe." However, the FAA does not recognize loop belts.
Similarly, many airplanes offer bassinets - baby-size beds that
can be strapped in beside a parent for the baby to sleep in. Again,
the FAA says they are not considered safety devices, noting that
there are no restraints and that the use of bassinets is banned
during takeoff and landing.
That leaves holding a child on your lap, an unappealing option for
any international flight of any length, or purchasing a space for
your child and then finding an appropriate child safety device.
Parents who decide on that option again face a myriad of tough
choices, says Martin Sperber, head of team aviation with TUEV
Rhineland, a German consumer safety organization.
"The whole topic is not very simple," he said. "It is very
complex."
So far, Sperber says, the best bet for a truly safe child seat on
an airplane is finding one with a label bearing the designation FMVSS
283, for Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards, a designation
granted by the US government.
Unfortunately, that test only looks at whether the seat meets
safety standards, he notes. It does not guarantee an approved seat
compatible with airline seats. Parents with a certified seat still
need to check with the airline to make sure it will work with the
seats on their airplanes.
And, even then, risks abound. Some airplanes use different seat
styles, sometimes even within a single passenger section. Sperber
says he has heard anecdotes of one couple failing to secure their
child's seat in an airplane while a couple of rows ahead of them,
another couple is installing theirs easily.
"Anything's possible," he said.
The only solution to the problem is standardization, he says. But
airlines are not keen on setting more restrictions for themselves and
governments face little pressure to draft standards, since most
people who would normally lobby for change are unaware of the
problem.
Those who are, often lose interest in the cause once their
children have grown up and can use standard airline seats.
Copyright 2009 dpa Deutsche Presse-Agentur GmbH